ROOTED IN SARASOTA. REFINED IN LUXURY.
Raised in Sarasota and refined by a corporate creative career in New York, Alison Stottlemyer brings a unique blend of local insight, marketing expertise, and strategic negotiation to every transaction. Specializing in Sarasota, Longboat Key, and Lakewood Ranch’s premier golf course communities and waterfront properties, she helps clients embrace the true Florida lifestyle — from fairways to shorelines. Rooted in authenticity and dedicated to results, Alison's business is built on trust, relationships, and delivering luxury with heart.
Alison has successfully sold over $75 Million in real estate, has been awarded the Coldwell Banker Presidential Elite Award for 2025, and has been awarded the Five Star Professional Award for Customer Satisfaction for the sixth year in a row.
Your Local, Full-Time Realtor
Watch this video to get to know more about Alison by clicking HERE>>>>GET TO KNOW ALISON STOTTLEMYER
Get a positive, helpful partner for buying or selling a home:
- Trusted resource for answers about the process
- Innovative marketing strategies
- Expertise about neighborhood features
- Powerful listening skills that translate into a focus on YOU
- Ability to target home searches
- Strong negotiation skills
- Support through the closing, and beyond
Check out my appearance on The Today Show, talking about some VERY good reasons to move to Florida!
Recent Sales
Alison is top-notch in every way. She really listened to what we wanted, she adjusted her strategy to find our perfect home as our interests changed, and she was so patient the whole way. She was flexible and willing to meet with us and do homework whenever we needed her. She is professional and kind while being a great negotiator and hands-on agent. We cannot say enough …
-Julie Prins, Client
Selling your home is such a challenging process. For us, we needed someone to take the reins, put the plan in place, remind us regularly of what needed doing, and recognize when a small thing could make a big difference. Who knew that a ceramic pineapple would resonate with our buyers? Well, Alison Aidlin Stottlemyer, our agent, did. If you want a full-service realtor …
-Kathy R., Client
After my first meeting with Alison, I knew that she was the person I wanted to work with. She spent the first day we toured homes trying to understand what I was looking for in a home. She explained how the entire process worked and answered all of my questions. She was great with dealing with me as a first time home buyer and wasn't put off by having to do a lot of …
-Sunya W, Client
I am so happy after hiring Alison as our listing realtor. She is a local, with a great attitude, and extensive knowledge of the area and market values. Alison gave us honest feedback and helped us at every turn. She communicated with us keeping us in the loop no matter what the news. She gave us great advice on staging the home and used technology to help market us in the …
-Adrienne S., Client
Alison was a complete breath of fresh air & not daunted by any obstacles. I had a very negative experience w/a previous realtor I had known for 30 yrs. After that experience, I was cynical & not very trusting. Alison was fantastic from the get go before we even met. First, unlike other realtors, she is not just seeking your listing to pile up her numbers. She listens very …
-Gisele P, Client
Communities Served
Alison's Support Team
Ellen C. O'Day - Real Estate Broker

Becca Fleishman - Transaction Coordinator

David Frankel - Office Support

Kathy Gulvas - Listing Concierge

Catherine Grieve - Coldwell Banker Legal Team

