Alison Stottlemyer, PA
Phone:
Phone:
M: 941.504.7260 mobile
Designations:
Certified Waterfront Specialist

Alison Stottlemyer, PA

REALTOR, Global Luxury

Alison pivoted to real estate from her career as a Beauty Industry Executive, where she specialized in Product Development for Victoria’s Secret Beauty (corporate) and Avon Global in NYC, where she created new fragrance and beauty brands. This was a beautiful integration of left-brain scientific and market analysis with right-brained creativity and innovation, all combined with having the skill of working with cross-functional teams and managing people. Her creative and analytical spirit has pivoted seamlessly to the real estate industry, where she works to provide the highest level of professional service and guidance to those considering selling or purchasing a property. Alison Stottlemyer's background, combined with her in-depth, decades-long understanding of the Sarasota market and lifestyle, is an incredible asset to her customers. She successfully utilizes both traditional and digital marketing to maximize exposure for sellers, and to provide comprehensive information for buyers, never losing sight of the value of the Human component. Always staying ahead of real estate trends and keeping on top of market fluctuations give Alison a competitive edge that is invaluable to her customers. Locally, Alison Aidlin Stottlemyer attended Pine View School for the Gifted and Riverview High School before she studied as a National Merit Scholar at the University of Florida; in Strasbourg, France, where she interned with the U.S. Consulate and Commercial Service; and received her Master’s degree at FIT in New York.

In her free time, Alison enjoys spending time with her family, being on the water, catching the latest play, watching live music, and trying to improve her pickleball and golf skills.

"Alison is everything you could want in a real estate agent and more. She is dedicated to doing whatever her clients need. When we visited Sarasota to search for a home, she spent an entire week with us looking at different types of homes in various locations in the area. And then after we left Sarasota, she continued to search for homes we might be interested in, even visiting several and giving us virtual tours by FaceTime. After we decided on a home, Alison’s guidance and continued assistance were invaluable in completing our purchase. Throughout the process, Alison was always energetic, cheerful, and responsive, and also on top of all the details. In short, Alison is a consummate professional as well as a delight to work and spend time with."

  -Lynne P, Client

"Alison was a complete breath of fresh air & not daunted by any obstacles. I had a very negative experience w/a previous realtor I had known for 30 yrs. After that experience, I was cynical & not very trusting. Alison was fantastic from the get go before we even met. First, unlike other realtors, she is not just seeking your listing to pile up her numbers. She listens very carefully, asks great questions, takes judicious notes, makes excellent recommendations & makes you feel as if you are her only client. The day my 1st offer came in, she was also negotiating 2 other contracts! She always called me back, offered sage advice, was wonderful psychologically w/ how I should proceed. She appealed to my business sense, has a great demeanor about her & is incredibly tenacious as well professional. Alison was so supportive, helpful & the consummate professional at every level. She guided me through everything & allayed my few fears. She was a great sounding board as well. "

  -Gisele P, Client

"Alison is top-notch in every way. She really listened to what we wanted, she adjusted her strategy to find our perfect home as our interests changed, and she was so patient the whole way. She was flexible and willing to meet with us and do homework whenever we needed her. She is professional and kind while being a great negotiator and hands-on agent. We cannot say enough positive about Alison and are so grateful for her tenacity, professionalism, friendship, kindness, and business acumen. Highly, highly, highly recommend Alison for all things real-estate. She's the best in the business and found us our dream home! #supreme #bluechip #topnotch #unparalleled #ultimate #unrivaled #simplythebest "

  -Julie Prins, Client

"After my first meeting with Alison, I knew that she was the person I wanted to work with. She spent the first day we toured homes trying to understand what I was looking for in a home. She explained how the entire process worked and answered all of my questions. She was great with dealing with me as a first time home buyer and wasn't put off by having to do a lot of hand-holding, with an indecisive buyer. The first weekend we went out to see houses in Sarasota and Bradenton, so I got a feel for different areas and neighborhoods. Alison was able to provide me with lots of background information on each area highlighting the pros and cons of each. She was there to guide me through each step of the process. Alison is genuine, trustworthy, knowledgeable, professional, patient and committed to making her client happy. There were days I was so frustrated, overwhelmed and discouraged. However, Alison would always say, "we will find the perfect home for you and your daughter". She was right!"

  -Sunya W, Client

Coldwell Banker Realty

 

CLICK HERE TO GET TO KNOW MORE ABOUT ALISON

 

Raised in Sarasota and refined by a corporate creative career in New York, Alison Stottlemyer brings a unique blend of local insight, marketing expertise, and strategic negotiation to every transaction. Specializing in Sarasota, Longboat Key, and Lakewood Ranch’s premier golf course communities and waterfront properties, she helps clients embrace the true Florida lifestyle — from fairways to shorelines. Rooted in authenticity and dedicated to results, Alison's business is built on trust, relationships, and delivering luxury with heart. 

Alison pivoted to real estate from her career as a Beauty Industry Executive, where she specialized in Product Development for Victoria’s Secret Beauty (corporate) and Avon Global in NYC, where she created new fragrance and beauty brands. This was a beautiful integration of left-brain scientific and market analysis with right-brained creativity and innovation, all combined with having the skill of working with cross-functional teams and managing people. Her creative and analytical spirit has pivoted seamlessly to the real estate industry, where she works to provide the highest level of professional service and guidance to those considering selling or purchasing a property. Alison Stottlemyer's background, combined with her in-depth, decades-long understanding of the Sarasota market and lifestyle, is an incredible asset to her customers. She successfully utilizes both traditional and digital marketing to maximize exposure for sellers, and to provide comprehensive information for buyers, never losing sight of the value of the Human component. Always staying ahead of real estate trends and keeping on top of market fluctuations give Alison a competitive edge that is invaluable to her customers. Locally, Alison Aidlin Stottlemyer attended Pine View School for the Gifted and Riverview High School before she studied as a National Merit Scholar at the University of Florida; in Strasbourg, France, where she interned with the U.S. Consulate and Commercial Service; and received her Master’s degree at FIT in New York.

In her free time, Alison enjoys spending time with her family, being on the water, catching the latest play, watching live music, and trying to improve her pickleball and golf skills.

Get to Know Alison Stottlemyer

  • Alison specializes in golf community homes, new construction, and waterfront properties.
  • Lifelong relationships have been and will always be key to Alison’s business. More than 95% of her business comes from the referrals of satisfied clients, past and present.
  • Valuing her 25 years of marketing experience, Alison’s clients and peers consistently rank her at the top of her profession.
  • Alison lives in Laurel Oak Estates and has gained a reputation as THE person to call in Laurel Oak, whether you'd like to sell for top dollar, or you'd like her to represent you as the Buyer, as she is a fierce and savvy negotiator.

ACCREDITATIONS & AWARDS:

  • Certified Luxury Home Marketing Specialist
  • Certified Real Estate Negotiator
  • Certified Waterfront Home Specialist
  • Five Star Real Estate Agent award winner every year since 2018, putting her at the top 1% of real estate agents for Customer Service
201 Gulf Of Mexico Dr
Longboat Key, FL
34228-4022